Skip to main content

Essay: Hurt Sentiments


Hurt Sentiments


 “Hurting Our Sentiments...” 

The above phrase currently provides both excuse and justification for certain special interests to indulge in wanton rioting and vandalism. What India needs is tough legislation, backed by even tougher police action and legal penalties to hurt the ability of such groups to hurt public order – and property.

Playboy once released a satirical video depicting a caricatured Mahatma Gandhi carousing with scantily-clad women. This televisual trash may have “hurt the sentiments” of the Indian diaspora but they had the good sense to deplore it in a civilized way. The tough attitude of the Chicago Police Department and the American Courts towards overly violent public demonstrations of moral outrage might have also had something to do with such model restraint. 



A Rajput caste grouping has recently threatened to “burn the nation” if the controversial film Padmavat about a fictional 13th - 14th century legendary queen of Chittor was released. This threat sits oddly with proud Rajput claims of being historic defenders of the Indian nation. Anyway, this assumed status did not avert numerous invasions of India by sundry outsiders in the past - the modern Indian Army and Seema Suraksha Bal (SSB) have had a far more successful track record as guardians of our country’s security. 

This kind of attitude was frequently satirized in American cartoonist Al Capp’s SWINE (Students Wildly Indignant Over Nearly Everything) whose hairy thugs regularly went on comic rampages. However, student demonstrations have now become relatively peaceful affairs in North America and Europe with minimal loss of life and damage to property; but it is quite telling that in the land of Gandhi and Ahimsa any kind of political or social grievance is seen as a general licence for unrestricted mob violence. A propensity now also to be seen in gangs of aggressive vigilantes who go by the titles of “Anti-Romeo Squads” and “Gau Rakshaks” lynching perceived offenders without the niceties of due legal process. 

This might be an unfortunate by-product of the past freedom struggle against the British Raj. That history established a culture of political protest that has now degenerated into mob violence for the sake of enjoying the adrenalin “high” engendered by unleashed aggression. Our country’s large population of disaffected unemployed youth also provide a large pool of recruits for the violent rent-a-mobs deployed by venal politicians. 



Matters aren’t helped by the fact that mobilizing violent mobs is seen by much of India’s political class as a valid form of public expression. Many of the country’s elected representatives seem to feel that inflicting death and destruction on their constituents is just politics as usual. Indeed, success in inciting mass riots with concomitant loss of life and property is probably a measure of proving one’s political prowess nowadays. 

Certain votaries of the present party in power feel free to openly incite murder online; especially of those who express dissenting political views or who have the temerity to criticize our “divine” Prime Minister. In any other civilized country governed by the rule of law, such worthies would be up before a court on charges of being a threat to public safety – and face the very real prospect of hefty fines and lengthy terms of imprisonment.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Book Review (Fiction) - Bad Dad

Bad Dad David Walliams Illustrated by Tony Ross HarperCollins Children’s Books 2017                                                   422 Pages           There once used to be a preachy school of sententious Victorian children’s fiction wherein the bad boy was eaten up by a lion for his wickedness; whilst the good boy came into deserved fame and fortune, before being drawn up to heaven by God and his angels. Thankfully, kid lit had come a long way since those awful days. Bad Dad is gleefully anarchic, but no less moralistic, plentiful comic havoc notwithstanding. The “Bad Dad” of the title isn’t really bad; he’s a racing champion crippled after a horrific crash and blackmailed into a life of crime thereafter as the getaway car driver for a cartoon trio of villains.  These three, led by the dwarfish, comically sinister Mr Big, are easily the funniest part of the book. The interplay between his two bickering minions “Fingers” and “Thumbs” constitutes a comedy

Book Review (Fiction) In The Valley OF Shadows

In The Valley Of Shadows Abhay Narayan Sapru Chlorophyll Books 2017                                             170 Pages The long guerrilla war waged against the British state by the IRA in Northern Ireland spawned a new literary sub-genre, “the troubles thriller” as practiced by authors such as Chris Petit ( The Psalm Killer ), Stephen Leather ( The Chinaman , The Bombmaker )  and Gerald Seymour ( Harry’s Game , Field Of Blood ) . The current conflict in Kashmir, with Pakistan-sponsored terrorist proxies attempting to wrest the state away from India, seems all set to follow suit .  Some of the growing tribe of authors in this nascent sub-genre have backgrounds in journalism covering the valley or have actually served in the Indian Army there. Major Abhay Narayan Sapru, late of the Indian Army Special Forces, belongs to the latter group. That’s what gives In The Valley Of Shadows it’s you-are-there ring of authenticity. The techniques and procedures u

Book Review (Fiction): Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine

Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine Gail Honeyman                                HarperCollins Publishers 2017                                                                       386 Pages Norman Bates of Psycho infamy had to live with the malign specter of “Mother” that drove him to murder. The eponymous Eleanor in Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine similarly labors under the ghost of poisonously murderous “Mummy” – but copes rather better than poor Norman ever did. At least, Eleanor never kills anyone. An abortive suicide attempt fortuitously interrupted doesn't count. Key to her survival (and relative sanity) are daily routines rigidly followed, her single-minded professionalism in an underpaid and thankless job as a finance administration assistant for a graphic arts agency and vodka-fueled weekends before the TV set in her Glasgow council flat. The British welfare state has much to commend it; one gets the feeling that had first-time author Gail Hon